Don't get transportation_name ref values from minor networks (#148)

src/main/java/com/onthegomap/planetiler/basemap/layers/TransportationName.java

@@ -121,6 +121,7 @@ public class TransportationName implements
   private final boolean sizeForShield;
   private final boolean limitMerge;
   private final PlanetilerConfig config;
+  private final boolean minorRefs;
   private Transportation transportation;
   private final LongByteMap motorwayJunctionHighwayClasses = Hppc.newLongByteHashMap();
 
@@ -141,6 +142,11 @@ public class TransportationName implements
       "transportation_name layer: limit merge so we don't combine different relations to help merge long highways",
       false
     );
+    this.minorRefs = config.arguments().getBoolean(
+      "transportation_name_minor_refs",
+      "transportation_name layer: include name and refs from minor road networks if not present on a way",
+      false
+    );
   }
 
   public void needsTransportationLayer(Transportation transportation) {
@@ -208,9 +214,22 @@ public class TransportationName implements
   public void process(Tables.OsmHighwayLinestring element, FeatureCollector features) {
     String ref = element.ref();
     List<Transportation.RouteRelation> relations = transportation.getRouteRelations(element);
-    Transportation.RouteRelation relation = relations.isEmpty() ? null : relations.get(0);
+    Transportation.RouteRelation firstRelationWithNetwork = relations.stream()
-    if (relation != null && nullIfEmpty(relation.ref()) != null) {
+      .filter(rel -> rel.networkType() != null)
-      ref = relation.ref();
+      .findFirst()
+      .orElse(null);
+
+    if (firstRelationWithNetwork != null && !nullOrEmpty(firstRelationWithNetwork.ref())) {
+      ref = firstRelationWithNetwork.ref();
+    }
+
+    // if transportation_name_minor_refs flag set and we don't have a ref yet, then pull it from any network
+    if (nullOrEmpty(ref) && minorRefs && !relations.isEmpty()) {
+      ref = relations.stream()
+        .map(r -> r.ref())
+        .filter(r -> !nullOrEmpty(r))
+        .findFirst()
+        .orElse(null);
     }
 
     String name = nullIfEmpty(element.name());
@@ -240,8 +259,8 @@ public class TransportationName implements
       .setAttr(Fields.REF, ref)
       .setAttr(Fields.REF_LENGTH, ref != null ? ref.length() : null)
       .setAttr(Fields.NETWORK,
-        (relation != null && relation.networkType() != null) ? relation.networkType().name :
+        firstRelationWithNetwork != null ? firstRelationWithNetwork.networkType().name : !nullOrEmpty(ref) ? "road" :
-          !nullOrEmpty(ref) ? "road" : null)
+          null)
       .setAttr(Fields.CLASS, highwayClass)
       .setAttr(Fields.SUBCLASS, highwaySubclass(highwayClass, null, highway))
       .setMinPixelSize(0)
@@ -267,7 +286,7 @@ public class TransportationName implements
     if (limitMerge) {
       feature
         .setAttr(LINK_TEMP_KEY, isLink ? 1 : 0)
-        .setAttr(RELATION_ID_TEMP_KEY, relation == null ? null : relation.id());
+        .setAttr(RELATION_ID_TEMP_KEY, firstRelationWithNetwork == null ? null : firstRelationWithNetwork.id());
     }
 
     if (isFootwayOrSteps(highway)) {

src/test/java/com/onthegomap/planetiler/basemap/layers/TransportationTest.java

@@ -341,15 +341,25 @@ public class TransportationTest extends AbstractLayerTest {
 
   @Test
   public void testRouteWithoutNetworkType() {
-    var rel = new OsmElement.Relation(1);
+    var rel1 = new OsmElement.Relation(1);
-    rel.setTag("type", "route");
+    rel1.setTag("type", "route");
-    rel.setTag("route", "road");
+    rel1.setTag("route", "road");
-    rel.setTag("network", "US:NJ:NJTP");
+    rel1.setTag("network", "US:NJ:NJTP");
-    rel.setTag("ref", "NJTP");
+    rel1.setTag("ref", "NJTP");
-    rel.setTag("name", "New Jersey Turnpike (mainline)");
+    rel1.setTag("name", "New Jersey Turnpike (mainline)");
+
+    var rel2 = new OsmElement.Relation(1);
+    rel2.setTag("type", "route");
+    rel2.setTag("route", "road");
+    rel2.setTag("network", "US:I");
+    rel2.setTag("ref", "95");
+    rel2.setTag("name", "I 95 (NJ)");
 
     FeatureCollector rendered = process(lineFeatureWithRelation(
-      profile.preprocessOsmRelation(rel),
+      Stream.concat(
+        profile.preprocessOsmRelation(rel1).stream(),
+        profile.preprocessOsmRelation(rel2).stream()
+      ).toList(),
       Map.of(
         "highway", "motorway",
         "name", "New Jersey Turnpike",
@@ -364,13 +374,94 @@ public class TransportationTest extends AbstractLayerTest {
       "_layer", "transportation_name",
       "class", "motorway",
       "name", "New Jersey Turnpike",
-      "ref", "NJTP",
+      "ref", "95",
-      "ref_length", 4,
+      "ref_length", 2,
-      "route_1", "US:NJ:NJTP=NJTP",
+      "route_1", "US:I=95",
+      "route_2", "US:NJ:NJTP=NJTP",
       "_minzoom", 6
     )), rendered);
   }
 
+  @Test
+  public void testMinorRouteRef() {
+    var rel1 = new OsmElement.Relation(1);
+    rel1.setTag("type", "route");
+    rel1.setTag("route", "road");
+    rel1.setTag("network", "rwn");
+    rel1.setTag("ref", "GFW");
+    rel1.setTag("name", "Georg-Fahrbach-Weg");
+
+    assertFeatures(13, List.of(mapOf(
+      "_layer", "transportation",
+      "class", "tertiary"
+    )), process(lineFeatureWithRelation(
+      profile.preprocessOsmRelation(rel1),
+      Map.of(
+        "highway", "tertiary"
+      ))));
+
+    var profileWithMinorRefs = new BasemapProfile(translations, PlanetilerConfig.from(Arguments.of(Map.of(
+      "transportation_name_minor_refs", "true"
+    ))), Stats.inMemory());
+
+    SourceFeature feature = lineFeatureWithRelation(
+      profileWithMinorRefs.preprocessOsmRelation(rel1),
+      Map.of(
+        "highway", "tertiary"
+      ));
+    var collector = featureCollectorFactory.get(feature);
+    profileWithMinorRefs.processFeature(feature, collector);
+    assertFeatures(13, List.of(mapOf(
+      "_layer", "transportation",
+      "class", "tertiary"
+    ), mapOf(
+      "_layer", "transportation_name",
+      "class", "tertiary",
+      "ref", "GFW",
+      "network", "road"
+    )), collector);
+  }
+
+  @Test
+  public void testPolishHighwayIssue165() {
+    var rel1 = new OsmElement.Relation(1);
+    rel1.setTag("type", "route");
+    rel1.setTag("route", "road");
+    rel1.setTag("network", "e-road");
+    rel1.setTag("ref", "E 77");
+    rel1.setTag("name", "European route E 77");
+
+    var rel2 = new OsmElement.Relation(2);
+    rel2.setTag("type", "route");
+    rel2.setTag("route", "road");
+    rel2.setTag("network", "e-road");
+    rel2.setTag("ref", "E 28");
+    rel2.setTag("name", "European route E 28");
+
+    FeatureCollector rendered = process(lineFeatureWithRelation(
+      Stream.concat(
+        profile.preprocessOsmRelation(rel1).stream(),
+        profile.preprocessOsmRelation(rel2).stream()
+      ).toList(),
+      Map.of(
+        "highway", "trunk",
+        "ref", "S7"
+      )));
+
+    assertFeatures(13, List.of(mapOf(
+      "_layer", "transportation",
+      "class", "trunk"
+    ), Map.of(
+      "_layer", "transportation_name",
+      "class", "trunk",
+      "name", "<null>",
+      "ref", "S7",
+      "ref_length", 2,
+      "route_1", "e-road=E 28",
+      "route_2", "e-road=E 77"
+    )), rendered);
+  }
+
   @Test
   public void testMotorwayJunction() {
     var otherNode1 = new OsmElement.Node(1, 1, 1);